Serving the Penn-Ohio area

Mehler Insurance | Insurance Agents | Sharpsville, PA

Personalized Insurance Services Since 1925

Located in Sharpsville, PA since 1925, Mehler Insurance represents 3 generations of commitment to high professional standards and personal service to the families and businesses of the Penn-Ohio area. Nothing is more gratifying to us than to welcome a new customer after having insured his or her parents and grandparents. Likewise, we are proud to have partnered with many local firms for 20 — even 40 years or more — and seen them grow from small start-ups to thriving and respected businesses.


Our salaried staff are all licensed agents and have decades of experience. As life-long residents of the area, we feel a personal concern for local families and businesses. Even with today’s technology that allows for expanded and prompter services, we still value face-to-face conversations with our customers to better assess their individual needs. As independent insurance agents, we have access to several markets to find the best coverage and value for your needs, whether simple or complex.


Earning our policyholders’ trust and loyalty is our bottom line.

Companies We Represent

Request An Insurance Quote

Aetna American Modern Insurance Group Banner Life CNA Surety Erie Insurance Foremost Insurance Group Hagerty Millville Mutual Philadelphia Insurance Companies Progressive Prudential United Healthcare

What’s New

We welcome Terry Jarocki as a producer to our agency.  He is eager to use his extensive expertise to solve your insurance coverage and afforability problems, in a friendly and helpful way.

UPMC logo Utica logo Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Markel